Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company
  • Home
  • Cheesecakes
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Testimonials
  • History of Cheesecake
  • Home
  • Cheesecakes
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Testimonials
  • History of Cheesecake
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

Cheesecakes

Please let us know if you have a favorite flavor not shown here and we will do our best to make it for you!

We offer a variety of sizes: Mini (individual), 6", 9" 

Feast your eyes on over 40 varieties of our award winning cheesecake!
Picture
Apple Pie
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Cheesecake and pie...the best of both worlds!  Our original cheesecake is drizzled with our gooey salted caramel sauce and heaped with our own apple pie filling!
Picture
Blueberry
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our original cheesecake is topped with our own delicious blueberry compote and whipped cream.
Picture
Caramel Pretzel
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Sweet and salty combine to make a heavenly treat!  Our original cheesecake is drizzled with our dreamy salted caramel sauce and topped with lots of pretzel pieces!
Picture
Cherry
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our original cheesecake is topped with our own delicious cherry compote and whipped cream.
Picture
Cherry Cordial
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
We start with our cookies and cream cheesecake, drizzle it with chocolate ganache, then top it with our own delicious cherry compote.  A fabulous combination!
Picture
Cherry Limeade
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our key lime cheesecake is a delight with real key lime juice right in the cheesecake and a light graham crust. It is topped with our own delicious cherry compote, our own whipped cream, and fresh lime zest.  An excellent combination of flavors!
Picture
Chocolate
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our rich, smooth chocolate cheesecake is made using the finest Callebaut cocoa and is topped with our own chocolate whipped cream and milk chocolate sprinkles.
Picture
Chocolate Cookie Latte
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
We start with our cookies and cream cheesecake, drizzle it with mocha ganache, then top it with our own espresso whipped cream and more chocolate cookie crumbles.  A perfect combination!
Picture
Chocolate Hazelnut
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our original cheesecake is topped with rich chocolate-hazelnut sauce.  A generous amount of chopped hazelnuts finishes it off.
Picture
Chocolate Orange
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
We start with our luscious chocolate cheesecake, top it with our own orange curd and dress it all up with a whipped cream border and dark chocolate wafer mini-loon cookies.
Picture
Chocolate Raspberry
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our rich, creamy chocolate cheesecake is heaped with our own intense raspberry coulis, and finished with our chocolate whipped cream and tart raspberry crumbles.
Picture
Chocolate Strawberry
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our rich, creamy chocolate cheesecake is drizzled with dark chocolate ganache and topped with our own strawberry compote, our chocolate whipped cream, and chocolate sprinkles.  Truly decadent!
Picture
Chocolate Truffle
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
We start with our rich chocolate cheesecake, top it with our own intense chocolate ganache and top it all off with chocolate sprinkles...a triple chocolate dream come true!
Picture
Confetti Craze
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our original cheesecake filling in a graham crust is topped with our smooth chocolate ganache and made festive with rainbow sprinkles. Perfect for a birthday or any special occasion!
Picture
Cookies and Cream
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
​
Chocolate sandwich cookie crumbles throughout our original creamy cheesecake filling in a chocolate cookie crust, all draped in our dark chocolate ganache, homemade whipped cream and more chocolate cookie crumbles.
Picture
Cranberry-Orange
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Fresh orange zest gives our orange cheesecake its zing. Our own cranberry-orange topping completes this delicious dessert.
Picture
Crumb Cake
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Sweet, tender crumb cake topping (the best part of any crumb cake!) adorns our original cheesecake to create our take on one of our favorite treats.
Picture
Cup of Joe
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
The way coffee should taste!  This coffee cheesecake with espresso whipped cream is perfect for those who like their coffee light and sweet.
Picture
German Chocolate Cheesecake
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Rich and creamy chocolate cheesecake in a chocolate crust, topped with our lovely combination of toasted pecans, toasted coconut, and caramel custard in a border of our chocolate ganache.
Picture
Gingerbread (SEASONAL)
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
A wonderful blend of spices gives our gingerbread cheesecake that "cookies fresh from the oven" taste...well, that and the cookies, of course!
Picture
Key Lime
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our key lime cheesecake is a delight with real key lime juice right in the cheesecake and a light graham crust. It is topped with our own sweet and tangy lime curd, our own whipped cream, and fresh lime zest.
Picture
Lemon Zinger
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our sweet and slightly tart lemon zinger cheesecake has fresh squeezed lemon juice right in the cheesecake and has a light graham crust. We top it with our own out-of-this-world lemon curd, our own whipped cream, and fresh lemon zest.
Picture
Lime in the Coconut
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
You will feel like you're on a Caribbean holiday when you taste this combination of coconut and key lime!
Picture
Maple Walnut
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Only real maple syrup is used when we make our maple walnut cheesecake, which sits in a "crust" of crushed walnuts.  Our own maple-walnut topping and our maple whipped cream top it off and more crushed walnut pieces give it the finishing touch.
Picture
Mint Chocolate Cookie
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
We start with our rich chocolate cheesecake, top it with our cool mint cream, drizzle that with chocolate ganache and add chocolate sandwich cookie crumbles for that perfect cookie texture.
Picture
Mocha Macchiato
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our bold, rich coffee cheesecake is made even more decadent with our chocolate ganache, espresso whipped cream, and chocolate cookie crumbles. 
Picture
New Hampshire Mud
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our rich chocolate cheesecake is topped with lots of gooey marshmallow cream, our dark chocolate ganache, and toasted pecans.  New Hampshire mud season sounds a lot better with our NH Mud cheesecake!
Picture
Orange Dream
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Fresh orange zest gives our orange cheesecake its zing. Top it with our own orange curd and whipped cream and you have sunshine on a cake plate!
Picture
Original
$26.88 (6")  /  $40.81 (9")

Ever the classic, our delicious original cheesecake is smooth and creamy and has a light and tender graham crust.
Picture
​Peanut Butter and Jelly
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our rich and creamy peanut butter cheesecake, topped with our strawberry compote in a border of our peanut butter buttercream.  An homage to everyone's favorite lunchbox sandwich!
Picture
Peanut Butter Cup
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our peanut butter cheesecake in a chocolate cookie crust, covered with our chocolate ganache, peanut butter frosting and peanut butter cups. A peanut butter lover's dream!
Picture
Peppermint Bark
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
A perfect combination of mint, chocolate, white chocolate, and cheesecake!  Our rich chocolate cheesecake is topped with white chocolate and crushed peppermint candies, giving our Peppermint Bark cheesecake it's festive flair.
Picture
Pumpkin (SEASONAL)
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Perfect for the fall and winter, our pumpkin cheesecake has a graham crust and our own wonderfully light cinnamon whipped cream. Our homemade ginger spice cookies top it all off!
Picture
Raspberry Dream
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
A confection of our original cheesecake, our own intense raspberry coulis and whipped cream, finished with tart raspberry crumbles.
Picture
Raspberry Lemonade
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
​
Our sweet and slightly tart lemon zinger cheesecake has fresh squeezed lemon juice right in the cheesecake and has a light graham crust. We top it with our own intense raspberry coulis, our own whipped cream, and fresh lemon zest.
Picture
Rum Eggnog (SEASONAL)
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
A holiday favorite, our rum eggnog cheesecake is sure to delight!  Made with spiced rum, spices and topped with our own whipped cream and ground nutmeg.
Picture
Salted Caramel
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our original cheesecake is drizzled with our ooey, gooey salted caramel sauce for that perfect sweet and salty mix!
Picture
Salted Caramel Macchiato
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our salted caramel sauce and espresso whipped cream top our rich coffee cheesecake to make this a tantalizing combination of bold, sweet, and salty.
Picture
Samoan
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our cookies and cream cheesecake is topped with our coconut topping, which sits between two layers of our sweet and salty caramel sauce.  All of this is drizzled with our decadent chocolate ganache.  
Picture
S'mores
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our chocolate cheesecake in a chocolate crust is drenched in toasted marshmallow cream and topped with chocolate-drizzled graham crackers and toasted marshmallows.
Picture
Strawberries and Cream
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Truly a classic...our delicious original cheesecake is heaped with our own strawberry compote and whipped cream.
Picture
Turtle
$38.49 (6")  /  $57.14 (9")
Our original filling in a chocolate crust, topped with chopped pecans and drizzled with our salted caramel sauce and our chocolate ganache.
Picture
What would you like to try?
We're always excited to try new cheesecake varieties...the sky is the limit!  Let us know what you have in mind as your Ultimate Cheesecake Flavor!

2" Miniature Cheesecakes

Miniature versions of nearly all of our cheesecakes are available individually or by the dozen, and can be ordered ahead in groups of four or more per flavor.  Mini cheesecakes are 2" in diameter (about the size of a cupcake). 
Picture
$5.57 (individual)
$61.22 (dozen of a single variety)

Dessert Doubleplays

​Can't decide between cake and cheesecake?  Why not have both?  These Dessert Doubleplays are truly the best of both worlds!
Picture
​Boston Cream (TO ORDER ONLY)
$71.55 Dozen Minis
$71.55 (6")  /  $120.84 (9")

A layer of our original cheesecake is topped with our own pastry cream and a layer of yellow cake. Our own chocolate ganache makes this a treat to remember.
Picture
Red Velvet (TO ORDER ONLY)
$71.55 Dozen Minis
$71.55 (6")  /  $120.84 (9")
​
A layer of our original cheesecake is topped with our own raspberry filling and a delightful layer of red velvet cake. Our own whipped cream finishes it off. A special dessert for the holidays!
Picture
Tuxedo (TO ORDER ONLY)
$71.55 Dozen Minis
$71.55 (6")  /  $120.84 (9")
A layer of our original cheesecake is topped with our own chocolate ganache and a delightful layer of chocolate fudge cake. Our own whipped cream finishes it off. A special dessert for special occasions!
Picture
Carrot (TO ORDER ONLY)
$71.55 Dozen Minis
$71.55 (6")  /  $120.84 (9")
A layer of our original cheesecake is topped with our cream cheese frosting and a scrumptious layer of our incredibly flavorful carrot cake. Our cream cheese frosting finishes it off. A delectable dessert for carrot cake lovers!

Cookies


​Looking for that special cookie for that special someone?  We have a variety of cookies available for pick up in our bakery, and are happy to make your custom cookies.  

Occasion Cakes and Cupcakes

We offer a variety of occasion cakes with your choice of cake, filling, frosting, writing, toppings.  Call for ideas and pricing.  Here are just some of your options:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
​Cake

Yellow Cake
Chocolate Fudge Cake
Carrot Cake
German Chocolate Cake​
Filling

​Vanilla Buttercream
Chocolate Buttercream
German Chocolate Filling
​Cream Cheese Filling

Whipped Cream

Blueberry
Cherry
Lemon Curd
Lime Curd
Orange Curd
​
Raspberry
Strawberry
​Chocolate Ganache

Frosting
​

Vanilla Buttercream
​
Chocolate Buttercream
German Chocolate Frosting
Cream Cheese Frosting
Whipped Cream
Chocolate Gana
che
​
Add-On Toppings

Chocolate Sprinkles
Rainbow Sprinkles
Toasted Coconut
​Chocolate Shavings
White Chocolate Chips
Chopped Almonds
Chopped Hazelnuts
​Chopped Pecans
Chopped Walnuts

More...

Candied pecans, caramels, toffee, candied pretzels, quick breads, coffee, tea...we make them all, fresh for you!
Web Hosting by iPage